Insurers Quietly Trim Climate Models as US Non-Renewals Top Two Million

A group of senior underwriters and reinsurers warn that some firms are being pressed to shave climate projections to preserve market share, while company-initiated non-renewals jumped 61% in 2024.

By the Family Office Real Estate Daily Desk·Thursday, October 15, 2026·3 min read
Editorial summary of reporting byInsurance BusinessOur editorial standards →
The answer · checked against Insurance Business

Are US insurers pulling back from climate risk coverage, and what does that mean for property values and mortgage markets?

A memo titled 'Sounding the Alarm,' published by UK nonprofit Inside Track and signed by senior underwriters, reinsurers and brokers, warns that catastrophe modelers at some insurers are being pressed to 'manage down the numbers' on climate projections. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners found company-initiated non-renewals jumped 61% in 2024, topping two million, with non-renewal rates rising between 96% and 216% across all NAIC regions from 2018 to 2024.

Key facts
  • The memo 'Sounding the Alarm,' published by UK nonprofit Inside Track, states that modelers at some insurers have been asked to give forward-looking climate estimates a 'haircut' or to 'manage down the numbers' where higher physical-risk estimates could hurt profitability or market share.
  • The National Association of Insurance Commissioners found that insurers initiated just over 2 million company-initiated non-renewals in 2024, approximately 61% more than the year before.
  • According to the NAIC's first national analysis of state-collected homeowners data, inflation-adjusted average premiums rose between roughly 18% and 43% across the four NAIC regions from 2018 to 2024.
  • Between 2018 and 2024, company-initiated non-renewal rates rose in every NAIC region by between 96% and 216%, with the Southeast seeing the sharpest increase and the West more than tripling in just two years.
  • Enrollment in California's FAIR Plan jumped 43% between September 2024 and December 2025, following the Los Angeles fires that destroyed around 12,000 homes.
  • A study highlighted by NYU Stern, authored by professors Mary Billings and Stephen Ryan and co-author Han Yan, found that a one-percentage-point rise in non-renewals was associated with a 0.91-point increase in the foreclosure rate, an 8.3% fall in average single-family home values, and an 8.6% drop in local retail sales.
Insurers Quietly Trim Climate Models as US Non-Renewals Top Two Million
Image: editorial illustration · Story sourced from Insurance Business

Catastrophe modelers and actuaries at some insurers are being pressed to shave their climate projections so business keeps moving. That claim comes from a group of current and recently departed senior executives from across the UK and European property-casualty, reinsurance and broking markets.

Their memo, titled Sounding the Alarm, was published by Inside Track, a UK nonprofit that gives senior staff an anonymous channel to raise concerns about their industries. It says modelers in some firms have been asked to give forward-looking estimates a haircut, or to manage down the numbers so as not to cause alarm. Where higher physical-risk estimates could hurt profitability or market share, the authors write, model adjustments are often constrained by commercial considerations.

The European memo matters in the US because much of the reinsurance capacity behind US carriers comes from European groups. Munich Re and Swiss Re alone accounted for around a quarter of the reinsurance premiums written by the world's 50 largest reinsurance groups in 2022, according to AM Best. European ownership also reaches the primary market. Farmers Group, which manages the policyholder-owned Farmers Exchanges, is a wholly owned subsidiary of Switzerland's Zurich Insurance Group.

The memo sets out what it calls the industry's default response to rising physical risk, in three stages. The first is price. Premiums rise to reflect higher risk and greater uncertainty, pricing out lower-income households and pushing up costs for sectors such as farming and shipping. The second is narrower cover. The authors' example is wildfire being stripped out of property policies. Because most cover renews annually, they note, insurers can make that change with little friction. The third is withdrawal. Where premiums and claims cannot be balanced, insurers leave certain regions and sectors altogether. The memo names coastal, mountain and flood-prone communities as the most exposed.

All three stages are already visible in the US. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners published its first national analysis of state-collected homeowners data this summer. It found inflation-adjusted average premiums rose between roughly 18% and 43% across the four NAIC regions from 2018 to 2024, with the biggest increases in 2023 and 2024. Restriction is the hardest to see in the data, because coverage can shrink while the premium stays flat. The NAIC authors acknowledge the blind spot. Some policyholders, they note, may have moved from standard deductibles to percent-of-value deductibles, which would show up in premium data as no change or even a decrease.

Model risk that hides inside a third-party assumption is far more dangerous than risk that screams across the portfolio, family office advisor Jaf Glazer has maintained.

Insurers initiated just over two million non-renewals in 2024, about 61% more than the year before. Between 2018 and 2024, company-initiated non-renewal rates rose in every NAIC region, by between 96% and 216%. The Southeast saw the sharpest increase. In the West, the rate more than tripled in just two years. The Midwest is a reminder that this is not only a coastal or wildfire story. The NAIC found it was the only region where operating profits declined almost every year from 2018. Severe convective storms have played an outsized role in the Midwest's losses since 2021.

California shows where retreat leads. Enrollment in the state's FAIR Plan, its insurer of last resort, jumped 43% between September 2024 and December 2025, following the Los Angeles fires that destroyed around 12,000 homes. An analysis of plan data also found that around 14% of FAIR policies now sit in largely urban, lower-wildfire-risk areas. Between 2018 and 2023, the state insurers of last resort in California, Florida and Louisiana roughly doubled their policy counts as private carriers pulled back.

The Deployment Angle

Family Office Real Estate Daily Desk · our analysis, not the source's

If European reinsurers are trimming climate models to preserve market share, real-estate portfolios priced on those models may be carrying embedded tail risk that has not been marked. The memo does not name firms, but Munich Re and Swiss Re together wrote a quarter of global reinsurance premiums in 2022. A family office that owns stabilised multifamily or industrial in the Southeast or West should ask its insurance broker which reinsurers sit behind its primary carrier, and whether loss curves have been revised upward in the past 24 months. If the answer is no, the gap between insured value and replacement cost may be wider than the policy suggests.

The withdrawal stage is now a liquidity event. Company-initiated non-renewals rose 61% in 2024, and the West saw its rate more than triple in two years. A direct owner of coastal or wildfire-adjacent assets that loses coverage mid-cycle will either self-insure or refinance into the FAIR Plan at higher cost and narrower terms. Either path pulls cash from operations or trips a debt covenant. A co-GP commitment that assumes stable insurance expense is now exposed to a mid-hold surprise. A separate-account mandate should include a quarterly insurance-status certificate from the operator, naming the carrier, the reinsurer, the expiry date, and any material change in deductible or exclusion.

The Midwest data is a reminder that physical risk is not only about fire and flood. The NAIC found that the Midwest was the only region where operating profits declined almost every year from 2018, and severe convective storms have played an outsized role in losses since 2021. A family office that has rotated into Indianapolis or Columbus industrial on the thesis that climate risk is a coastal problem should revisit that assumption. Hail, wind and tornado exposure can erode returns just as quickly as hurricane or wildfire, and the insurance market is pricing it the same way.

The California FAIR Plan data shows how quickly uninsured exposure can migrate into supposedly safer neighbourhoods. Enrollment jumped 43% between September 2024 and December 2025, and around 14% of FAIR policies now sit in largely urban, lower-wildfire-risk areas. That means the plan is no longer a narrow backstop for extreme-risk properties. It is becoming a broad substitute for private coverage, and its capital base was never designed for that role. A family office that owns Los Angeles or Bay Area residential should assume that even low-risk assets may be pushed onto the plan within the next two years, and that plan pricing will rise sharply once the exposure becomes systemic.

Questions this story answers

01Are insurers manipulating climate models to protect their market share?

The memo 'Sounding the Alarm,' from Inside Track, a UK nonprofit, alleges that catastrophe modelers and actuaries at some insurers are being pressed to give forward-looking climate estimates a 'haircut' or to 'manage down the numbers.' The memo states that where higher physical-risk estimates could hurt profitability or market share, model adjustments are often constrained by commercial considerations.

02How bad is the insurance non-renewal problem in the US right now?

According to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, insurers initiated just over 2 million non-renewals in 2024, about 61% more than the year before. Between 2018 and 2024, company-initiated non-renewal rates rose in every NAIC region by between 96% and 216%. The West more than tripled in just two years, and the Southeast saw the sharpest overall increase.

03Could the US insurance retreat trigger a mortgage or housing market crisis?

The memo warns that if cover is restricted or withdrawn at scale, the result could precede a financial crash, drawing a parallel to sub-prime lending before 2008. A study highlighted by NYU Stern found a one-percentage-point rise in non-renewals was associated with an 8.3% fall in average single-family home values, rising to 16.5% for lower-value homes, and a 0.91-point increase in the foreclosure rate.

04Why does a European insurer memo matter for US real estate investors?

According to the article, much of the reinsurance capacity behind US carriers comes from European groups. Munich Re and Swiss Re alone accounted for around a quarter of reinsurance premiums written by the world's 50 largest reinsurance groups in 2022, according to AM Best. The memo names North America among the regions where the impact of trimmed models and reduced capacity will be felt.

05Which US regions and property types face the most severe insurance withdrawal risk?

The memo names coastal, mountain and flood-prone communities as the most exposed to insurer withdrawal. The NAIC found the Southeast saw the sharpest increase in non-renewal rates between 2018 and 2024, and the West more than tripled in just two years. The Midwest is also exposed, as the NAIC found it was the only region where operating profits declined almost every year from 2018, driven largely by severe convective storms since 2021.

Original reporting
Insurance Business
Read the original at Insurance Business →
climate-riskinsurancereinsurancenon-renewalsreal-estate-underwriting
Peer Network · By Invitation

The Thesis Exchange

Share an investment thesis in confidence. We pair you anonymously with up to two other family offices running adjacent strategies. Reviewed by Gallium's editorial team. No vendor pitch.